Erik Stifler (John White) and his pal Mike “Cooze” Coozeman (Jake Siegel) have graduate high school and are going to college. They think they’ve got an easy in because Erik’s cousin Dwight (Steve Talley) is in the hard-partying Beta House. The house faces some competition when the Geek House, who want the Betas thrown off of campus.

They eventually challenge the Betas to the banned Greek Olympiad competition. The former winner of the games returns to judge the games – Mr. Levenstein (Eugene Levy). Meanwhile, the somewhat virginal (kinda) Erik has fallen for Ashley (Meghan Heffern) but must both compete in the games as well as pass the arduous (well not really) Olympiad.